data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2fab2/2fab2cd9e50f66e0999a42cd11bfa3aa43c4efc1" alt="business texting
power washing business
cleaning business
communication
roof cleaning
soft washing"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bc48f/bc48fe4b82454f135a175845f7d17f694c4ea86e" alt="soft wash
power washing
Softwash
Powerwash
house wash
roof cleaning"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f9821/f9821bb1bc7898514c85d04fd803bb8701fc84ac" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8c4cf/8c4cf044e0ae2975b66e54b1495d1879d5dfca63" alt="cost of cedar, cedar siding"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/34b6b/34b6b995c92d8c782fd32232f7e80562d6974f4e" alt=""
Here's the scenario: a family buys a home on Cape Cod, does zero
maintenance on it for 5 or 10 years, then realizes that the mahogany
deck is looking shabby. Mold, mildew, and algae is discoloring it, and
some lichen is growing on the ends of the boards way over in the shade.
They call Outside Cleaners,
and we come take a look. We see that the deck is well-built: properly
supported, constructed with stainless hardware, proper gaps between
decking boards, etc. No problem. We can clean it up for hardly more
than it would take the homeowner to rent a power washer, buy some oxygen bleach, and wash it themselves.
We promptly e-mail a proposal to the homeowner, and then never hear
back. Four days becomes a week. After ten days, I call the homeowner
to make sure they got our proposal. Yes they did, but they're no longer
interested in having it cleaned because they're going to just replace
it all with plastic decking "so that they don't have to worry about it
again."
...
Ahhh, where to begin? They think a plastic deck will somehow carve
their Cape Cod happiness in stone. We see that mentality often, and can
only shake our heads. Yes, that plastic decking will still be intact
in a landfill a thousand years after we've all turned to dust, but that
doesn't mean the decking will look good
during it's advertised
service life! We've long since lost count of the number of plastic
decks we've seen which have been permanently stained by sunscreen, sap,
food grease, and even water moisture
! And while we're aware of
products and services which claim to fix stains on plastic and composite
decking, we've yet to see one (really, not ONE) which works as
advertised.
What we HAVE regularly seen is plastic deck owners with buyers remorse.
We meet them with incredible regularity. Among the lamentations we've
heard: They didn't realize...
1) ... how expensive the decking was.
2) ... their old deck, which was made to support stiff mahogany or
pressure-treated decking, needed to be modified to properly support the
flimsier plastic or composite decking. $$$
3) ... how often those plastic decking companies go out of business, only to re-form under a different name.
4) ... the company behind their warranty went bankrupt.
5) ...they'll still need to clean the plastic deck, or permanent discoloration or deterioration can occur.
6) ...when they go to expand the deck in the future, they won't be able
to match the decking color with their old decking because companies
change their colors with comical regularity.
7) ... how easily the plastic or composite decking stains.
8) ... how hot the composite decking gets when in the sun.
If I could tell a future deck owner something, it would be this: Maybe a
plastic deck is right for you, but maybe it isn't. Everything needs
some maintenance from time to time. Nothing lasts forever. Read
reviews, and read the fine print. Don't believe in it when it's brand
new and unproven in the real world. Don't believe everything you see in
their glossy ads.